First poster for Ryan Murphy’s new series ‘ALL'S FAIR’ starring Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, Teyana Taylor, Sarah Paulson and Glenn Close.

 

First poster for Ryan Murphy’s new series ‘ALL'S FAIR’ starring Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, Teyana Taylor, Sarah Paulson and Glenn Close. pic.twitter.com/Nnu43l0evr

— Pop Base (@PopBase) May 13, 2025

On May 13, 2025, Pop Base shared the first official poster for Ryan Murphy’s upcoming Hulu legal drama *All’s Fair*, set to premiere in Fall 2025. The series boasts an impressive ensemble cast, including Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, Teyana Taylor, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close. The poster, featuring the tagline “Never Settle,” prominently positions Kim Kardashian at the center, dressed in a striking red suit, while the other actresses flank her in shades of purple and pink against a backdrop of bookshelves. The show follows a team of female divorce attorneys who leave a male-dominated firm to start their own practice, navigating high-stakes cases and personal drama. The teaser trailer, released alongside the poster, highlights Kardashian as a ruthless divorce lawyer, with Glenn Close delivering a fiery line: “Get mad! Get hot! Get revenge!” However, the decision to place Kardashian front and center has ignited a heated discussion among fans and critics alike.

The reveal of *All’s Fair* has generated significant buzz, but not all of it is positive. Ryan Murphy, known for hits like *American Horror Story* and *Glee*, has a knack for assembling star-studded casts and delivering visually striking dramas, and this project appears to be no exception. The premise—an all-female law firm tackling messy divorces while facing internal conflicts—promises a mix of glamour, power struggles, and emotional depth, which aligns with Murphy’s signature style. The inclusion of heavyweights like Sarah Paulson and Glenn Close, both of whom have extensive accolades, alongside Naomi Watts and Niecy Nash, sets high expectations for the series’ acting chops.

However, the spotlight on Kim Kardashian has become a lightning rod for controversy. While Kardashian has been dipping her toes into acting—most notably in *American Horror Story: Delicate*—her placement at the forefront of the poster, ahead of Emmy and Oscar-nominated actresses, has left many fans scratching their heads. Reactions on X range from confusion to outright frustration, with users like @LeeLovesBey calling it “crazy” to prioritize Kardashian over her more seasoned co-stars, and @kylepalms88 labeling it a “disgrace.” Others, like @Ginny, argue that the move is a deliberate marketing stunt designed to generate buzz through controversy, pointing out that Kardashian’s polarizing presence guarantees clicks and conversation.

There’s merit to both sides of the debate. On one hand, Kardashian’s involvement brings undeniable star power and a massive audience, which could help a new series like *All’s Fair* stand out in a crowded streaming landscape. Her real-life connection to the legal world—her late father, Robert Kardashian Sr., was a prominent attorney, and she’s currently pursuing a law degree—adds a layer of authenticity to her role as a divorce lawyer. On the other hand, placing her ahead of acting veterans like Glenn Close, who has been nominated for eight Oscars, or Sarah Paulson, a staple in Murphy’s projects, risks alienating fans who value merit over marketability. It’s a bold choice that could either pay off by broadening the show’s appeal or backfire if audiences feel her performance doesn’t measure up.

Ultimately, *All’s Fair* looks poised to be a flashy, drama-filled addition to Hulu’s lineup, but its success may hinge on whether it can balance its high-profile casting with a compelling story. For now, the controversy surrounding the poster has ensured that all eyes will be on the series when it debuts this fall. Will Kardashian prove her detractors wrong, or will the ensemble’s veterans steal the show? We’ll have to wait and see.